WEST MILTON, Ohio — A quiet community is grappling with grief and disbelief after a tragic murder-suicide left three people dead early Saturday morning, October 27, 2025.
Authorities have identified the deceased as Jacob E. Prichard, 34, his wife Jaymee M. Prichard, 33, and his coworker Jaime S. Gustitus, 25. According to preliminary reports from law enforcement, officers responded to a residence in West Milton following reports of gunfire. Upon arrival, they discovered all three individuals deceased at the scene.
Investigators believe the incident was the result of a murder-suicide, though the exact circumstances remain under investigation. Officials have stated that there is no ongoing threat to the public.
Neighbors described the Prichards as a friendly couple and expressed shock at the tragedy that has shaken their normally peaceful neighborhood. “You never think something like this could happen here,” one resident said. “Everyone is heartbroken.”
The Miami County Sheriff’s Office, in coordination with the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation, continues to gather evidence as the investigation unfolds. Authorities have asked for privacy for the victims’ families as they navigate this devastating loss.
Community leaders and grief counselors are offering support to those affected, emphasizing the importance of coming together in the wake of such tragedy.